Makeup should enhance your features and make you feel good, not cause an adverse reaction. When you put eyeliner on, you want to glow and be glamorous, but sensitive eyes can cause your cosmetics application to backfire. We had our experts conduct careful research and review to bring you a top ten list of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes, so you can get back to painting the town red in style. Here’s what to look for when shopping.
Waterproof: Rain? Sad movie? If you’re like most makeup lovers, you appreciate waterproof features. We don’t want you to get stuck looking like a raccoon, so check this spec if being waterproof is on your list of must-haves.
Color: We bet you look great in any color, but everyone has their favorite. If you’re looking for a specific shade, or want to avoid picking a hue that doesn’t work for you, check this spec for your color options for each of the eyeliners on our list.
Type: Different strokes for different folks. We bet it took you a long time to master your eyeliner and we don’t want to mess that up. Whether you’re a liquid or pencil fan, this spec will tell you which method of delivery each of the eyeliners on our lists features.
Organic: If you want to avoid preservatives and chemicals, we have you covered with our organic options. Check this spec for information on whether the eyeliner you like is free from ingredients that make you uncomfortable.
Smudge-Proof: After you spent the last several minutes perfecting the perfect wing, the last thing you need is to worry if it’s intact for the rest of the day. We want you to be confident, so we’ll let you if the eyeliner is smudge-proof.
Weight: It’s a good idea to know how much you’re getting, so you can make the right choice for your needs and budget. Check this spec to see how many ounces each product contains.
Now that we’ve covered what to look for, you’re ready to start shopping. We’ve compiled the most important information about each of our top ten options to help you make an educated choice. Whether you’re looking for the best waterproof eyeliner for swimming or you just need a good eyeliner for sensitive eyes, we feel confident you’ll find what you desire on our list. Keep the specifications important to you in mind and let’s get started!
Getting a stunning look can be as easy as finding the right eyeliner for you; there are tons of irresistible shades for you to apply. If you have sensitive eyes, though, you're going to need a product designed to be gentle. Picking out which eyeliner for sensitive eyes will best fit your needs shouldn’t be hard; there are a few things you should keep in mind when looking through brands that we’ve included below.
You have a few options when applying eyeliner, depending on your preference you can either use a classic pencil liner or a liquid liner.
Pencil liner is the classic form of eyeliner that's been used for decades. You can choose between the traditional wooden pencil or a self-sharpening mechanical model. Pencil liners tend to use fewer chemicals than their liquid equivalents. Pencil liners tend to stay good longer, but can be messy when you're sharpening them.
+ Less Chemicals
+ Mechanical Options Available
- Messy Sharpening
- Can Crumble Easily
Liquid liners take out the messy step of sharpening a pencil with a vast selection of hues. These liners can have serums added to further help enhance your eyes. Liquid liners have a huge variety of colors and mixtures but are more prone to bothering sensitive eyes.
+ Large Selection of Colors
+ Serums Can Be Added In
- More Chemicals
- Goes Bad Faster
Even eyeliner has a few basics you should look into before buying a stick. Keep reading below to learn the basics of picking a new liner.
When you have sensitive eyes, you have more to worry about when purchasing eye makeup. There are many chemicals that go into giving eyeliner their pigments and staying power. Liquid liners may be packed with even more additives to help keep its gel-like nature. Look for liners that use the fewest ingredients, anything using carbon black, a chemical that can cause toxicity, should be especially avoided.
Every eyeliner has a different amount of staying power. Depending on the formula, eyeliner can stay on your eyes for different durations of time. For all-day wear, look for formulas made for 8 to 12-hour wear. If you have to use make-up remover to get it off at the end of the day, then you have found a good liner.
Eyeliner comes in a vast rainbow of colors, including unique mixes like metallics or pearlescent. You can find virtually every color under the rainbow in a liner. Make sure to do a swatch test to know precisely how vibrant a liner will be.
Pencil eyeliner will last around a year after being unsealed. Liquid Liners have a much shorter life and need to be replaced around every three months. When kept for too long, an eyeliner will become less effective and can have a build-up of bacteria.
Here are a few tips for making sure the application process goes smoothly.
When using a pencil liner, you will want to sharpen regularly. Keep from giving your eyeliner to fine of a point and use a sharpener designed for make-up to avoid crumbling or splintering. If you pencil splinters, make sure to file it down before use.
If you're using a liquid liner, it’s best to start from the middle of your eye and then fill in the gaps. Pencil liners apply best when you start from the inner corner of your eye. Be sure to do the lid and under eye in separate swipes.
Avoid using tons of pressure when putting on a liner. Lightly glide your liner on, if you have sensitive eyes, use your finger to keep your eyes open for easy application. Always use a mirror to make sure you're hitting all the right spots. Make sure to take the process at your own pace to avoid injury.
It’s best to remove your eyeliner any time you feel irritation. Make sure to always remove make-up before going to bed to avoid damage to your skin in the long run. Don’t panic if you fall asleep occasionally without removing your liner; it takes long stents of time for eye make-up to start causing damage.
If you're using eyeliner to enhance your look, then there are a few accessories you can pick-up to make you look like a pro. Whether you need to protect your eyes or ensure cleaner lines, these accessories will enhance your make-up routine.
Make-up remover is a must for anyone that uses eyeliner. Eye make-up remover helps you safely remove your make-up each day. There are a variety of make removers, including oil-based remover for liquid liners and hard to remove pencil. For easy to remove liners, there are cleansing water removers.
If you're using a wooden pencil, then just any sharpener won’t do. You should pick up a sharpener made specifically for your liner to get the most out of your make-up.
Even if you have an unsteady hand, an eyeliner guide can help you make straight lines. These devices are made to hold over your eyes and direct your liner down a straight path. Eyeliner guides will keep you from having uneven lines saving you from having to redo your make-up.
If you want to go the extra mile, then check-out eyeliner stencils. These help you give your eyes fun looks without having to worry about a steady hand. Many stencils offer multiple looks for you to choose from.
If your going out in bad weather or have a long workday, then you need your make-up to stay in place. Using an eyeliner seal helps to keep your liner in place so you can look your best no matter the situation. There are plenty of seals that use a coating made for sensitive eyes.
Expert Researcher and Writer
Heather Patton is a lead researcher and writer at GeekWrapped. She has been creating high-quality content for over a decade and covers home, lifestyle, beauty, fashion products and more.
Article last updated on:
October 10, 2019