Disclosure: GeekWrapped helps you find the best stuff. When readers buy the independently
chosen products on this site, we earn a commission that supports our work. Find our guides here.
Disclosure: GeekWrapped helps you find the best stuff. When readers buy the independently chosen products on this site, we earn a commission that supports our work.
Disclosure: When readers buy the independently chosen products on this site, we earn a commission.

Best Newborn Pacifiers

Expert Reviews & Buying Guide

quadcopter reviewsBest Newborn Pacifiers

Our Recommendations

In a hurry? Here are the best products at a glance.

Trusted by millions of readers. As featured in
Expert Reviews Buying Guides

How to Choose the Best Newborn Pacifier

You’re welcoming a precious little being into your life and you want to be sure they have the best newborn pacifiers to keep them happy and comforted. You might be wondering which pacifiers are made from the safest materials and have the most appropriate design for tiny mouths. Our experts researched and reviewed a range of options to bring you the premium options on the market. Before we get started, let’s take a look at some of the specifications to keep in mind while shopping

Best Newborn Pacifiers

BPA-Free: Recently, it was revealed to the public that BPA in plastic can have lasting, negative effects. If BPA-free is important to you, check this spec for details on the manufacturing standards for each pacifier.

Best Newborn Pacifiers

Material: Pacifiers comes in a range of materials, including silicone and rubber. Different materials provide different experiences. We’ve provided information on what each of our picks is made from.

How to Choose the Best Newborn Pacifier

Age Range: Sold in different sizes for the different stages of infancy, you need to be sure the pacifier you’re picking is appropriate for newborns. Some pacifiers range from 0-3 months, while others can be used up to six months.

Best Newborn Pacifiers

Colors: This spec is more for you, since your baby will only be concerned with comfort provided by a binky, but we understand that you want the cutest, most stylish pacifier for the special little one in your life, so we’ll let you know what your options are.

Best Newborn Pacifiers

1-Piece Design: Some pacifiers are one molded piece, while others are the sum of a nipple and plastic backing. Each design has its separate benefits. We’ll let you know which design each pacifier is with this spec.

Product Intro Icon

Set Pieces: Double the fun with a set of two! Some of our picks come with a bonus pacifier. Check this spec to determine how many pacifiers come with each bundle.

Top 10 Products

Let’s get right to our top rated pacifiers. We’ve included our favorite top pick and an affordable budget pick, to help you make the perfect choice. Whether you’re specifically looking for newborn pacifiers for breastfed babies or simply seeking top rated pacifiers that are durable and made with safe materials, all ten options are excellent choices. Let’s get shopping!

Natursutton Natural Rubber Pacifier

Top Pick
Made from natural rubber from the Hevea Brasiliensi tree, our top pick is a leader in hygienic design. Bacteria doesn’t stand a chance against this one-piece, molded pacifier! It eliminates any cracks or crevices where germs could grow, keeping baby healthy and protected from unnecessary exposure to harmful organisms. Manufactured without BPA, phthalates, or PVC, the Natursutton is formulated with only the safest ingredients. It conforms to European standards and its name literally means “natural pacifier” in Danish. When you’re looking for the best pacifiers for breastfeeding newborn babies, don’t overlook this sensational option. Perfect for babies from 0-6 months old, the handled sides double as an excellent teether. Durable rubber makes it so you never have to worry about the tip breaking off. Keep baby comfortable and relaxed with this ultra-safe, lasting pacifier that lets you feel good about what you give your kids. It’s an excellent design and well worth the affordable price.
Check Price NowReview Top Pick

Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier

Budget Pick
AVENT is a leading name in quality baby products. Ask any parent and they’ll tell you that AVENT pacifiers and bottles offer a unique, beneficial design. The Soothie is perfect for babies aged 0-3 months and comes in a pack of two! You can’t beat a two-for-the-price-of-one deal! And if this is your first run at being a parent, you don’t know it yet, but pacifiers tend to disappear easily. Having an extra one on hand in the middle of the night is nothing short of a miracle! The 1-piece molded construction means bacteria won’t fester in between cracks where moisture can get caught. BPA and latex-free and made from silicone, this is the pacifier of choice used in hospitals around the country. It was specifically designed with a baby’s mouth in mind, making it a top contender in the search for the best pacifier for breastfeeding. Stock up on these awesome pacis without taking a hit to your wallet.
Check Price NowReview Budget Pick

MAM Orthodontic Pacifier

The MAM is a lifelike pacifier that accounts for all of baby’s comfort and development. The silicone nipple flattens and lengthens during suckling, mimicking the feel of a human nipple, making MAM one of the best pacifiers for breastfed newborns on the market! It will be difficult for baby to tell the difference, resulting in an ultra-relaxing experience that lulls your little one gently to sleep. Specifically created with your baby’s orthodontic development in mind, all MAM pacifiers are designed to promote healthy oral development. No matter which way you place the MAM in your baby’s mouth, it will not adversely affect tooth or gum health. The innovative curved shield is designed with large air holes to minimize skin irritation while resting on baby’s cheeks. And get this: all MAM pacifiers are free from BPA, BPS, lead, and phthalates, so you know you’re making a safe choice. Sold in a pack of two and featuring adorable forest creatures, you’ll be surprised at how affordable these pacifiers are!
Check Price Now

The First Years GumDrop Pacifier

Soothe the little gumdrop in your life with the First Years GumDrop pacifier. Sold as a two-pack and promoted by hospitals worldwide, the GumDrop is BPA-free, latex-free, and phthalate-free. Its silicone one piece design is shaped to avoid baby’s nose to promote easy breathing. You never have to worry that this pacifier is blocking your child’s airways for two reasons. The obvious first reason is the well-intentioned shape. The second is that, being one piece, the tip will never break off. When it comes to safety, GumDrop has taken serious measures to bring you a premium design. We know safety and health are at the top of your list when you make the search for the best pacifier for newborn. That’s why we’re confident you’ll love the GumDrop as much as we do. And here’s the kicker: it easily works with most pacifier attachers. Between the extra pacifier and the option to attach to a lead linked to baby’s shirt, you should never have to worry about running low on clean binkies.
Check Price Now

Tommee Tippee Everyday Pacifier

When your baby is crying, you want to do everything you can to make him or her feel better. Tommee Tippee designed a pacifier to help you calm your little bundle and soothe your own nerves. The Everyday pacifier has a shield-style nipple that mimics the nipple on a bottle. This is great if you plan to bottle-feed because baby won’t get confused and reject the pacifier, after becoming accustomed to the nipple on a bottle. The similar design provides for a convenient switch between the two, so baby stays relaxed. This ingenious nipple is also symmetrical to promote orthodontic health. No matter which way your baby sticks this pacifier into his or her mouth, the teeth and gums will remain unaffected! Additionally, the nipple design promotes balance, so baby will be able to easily hold the pacifier in between the tongue and roof of the mouth. A leading, trusted name when it comes to the world of baby gear, Tommee Tippee provides some of the best baby pacifiers for today’s modern family.
Check Price Now

WubbaNub Monkey Pacifier

Baby’s first friend! The WubbaNub is a super unique design that combines pacifier and lovey animal into one. Now your baby can easily grip the pacifier, thanks to the monkey friend securely attached to the opposite side. Apart from its adorable design, the WubbaNub offers safety and functionality. BPA, PVC, latex, and phthalate-free, this silicone pacifier is a one-piece design that ensures proper hygiene. A lack of cracks and crevices on this pacifier makes moisture dry quickly and keeps germs at bay. Trusted by professionals all over the country, the WubbaNub is among the top pacifiers commonly distributed in hospitals and NICU units, due to its comforting construction and outstanding safety features. Although the monkey and pacifier do not detach from each other, the WubbaNub is easy to care for. The entire unit can be thrown into the washer on gentle cycle and then hung to air dry. When it comes to cute, WubbaNub wins.
Check Price Now

Philips Notched Soothie Pacifier

Calming, soothing, and featuring a curved design that promotes easy breathing, the Philips Notched Soothie is a premium pacifier that prioritizes comfort and health. Your baby deserves the best of both worlds, and the Notched Soothie delivers! It is transparent, odorless, and tasteless, so baby reaps the benefits of a relaxing suckling experience without any added unpleasant details. The nipple resists becoming sticky, which keeps bacteria from growing. This durable pacifier never stains or becomes misshapen. Its symmetrical design also promotes natural oral development, allowing parents to rest easy alongside baby. Sold in a two-pack, this hospital-grade BPA-free, latex-free, silicone pacifier is dishwasher-safe for the ultimate convenience and ranks as one of our favorite newborn pacifiers for breastfed babies.
Check Price Now

NUK Orthodontic Pacifier

With a 100 percent silicone one-piece construction, you don’t need to worry about nasty germs or bacteria! The NUK Orthodontic Pacifier offers a practical design that promotes oral health, excellent hygiene, and safety. Created for babies from 0-3 months, its asymmetrical shape fits to the baby’s palate and helps to exercise the tongue and jaw. A scooped nipple cavity allows for maximum tongue movement and integrated channels make for less palate pressure than competing designs. The soft silicone leaves baby’s skin feeling soothed and won’t irritate. A depressed top promotes easy breathing, by staying clear of baby’s little nose. The unique design aimed at flexible suction makes the NUK one of our picks for best pacifiers for breastfeeding newborn babies. Even better, it comes in a two-pack, so you can always have a clean, sanitized extra on hand. These two premium pacifiers are available at a deal, so you don’t want to miss out!
Check Price Now

RaZbaby JollyPop Pacifier

The RaZbaby JollyPop looks as fun as it sounds! Available in three colors, this transparent pacifier with a dark-colored rim is BPA-free and made from hospital-grade silicone. Created according to stringent health and safety guidelines, it is molded into a one-piece design. You can be sure baby is suckling away at a pacifier that won’t get make him or her sick. In fact, germs won’t find a home anywhere on this model, due to its open-air design. Created to support your baby’s natural orthodontic development, rest assured the JollyPop won’t result in tooth or gum issues, either. You don’t have to sacrifice a thing when it comes to the JollyPop, because all bases are covered to bring you the best pacifier possible. Best of all, it is ultra-durable, dishwasher-safe, and can be easily sterilized. When it comes to the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, the calming nipple on this awesome pacifier is the perfect option.
Check Price Now

Baby Fanatic Pacifier Set

Game day will never be the same, now that you have the best sidekick ever! Deck your little one out with one of these awesome Baby Fanatic pacifiers, sold in a set, and featuring forty different NFL teams! Now baby can show his or her support for your favorite team, too! But style isn’t the only awesome feature offered by this pacifier. With a slanted orthodontic nipple, you can feel good about equipping your bundle of joy with Baby Fanatic, because it won’t adversely affect oral health. BPA-free and made from silicone, these pacifiers are healthy and safe, too! Perfect for little ones from newborn up until six months, the Baby Fanatic lasts for the entire season. It makes the perfect gift for your favorite baby and the sports enthusiasts in his or her life. If the game is a main event in your home, and you’re looking for the best pacifier for newborn babies, look no further!
Check Price Now

Discover New Gift Ideas Now

Unique Geek Gifts


Privacy guaranteed. Emails are never shared.
By clicking "Get Access" you agree to
our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. All prices on this site may change and those considered valid are displayed on Amazon.com
Review and Buying Guide GeekWrapped