Best Organic Eyeshadows

Top 10 Buying Guide

Best Organic Eyeshadows

Our Recommendations

In a hurry? Here are the best products at a glance.

HONEST REVIEWS
Trusted by millions of readers. As featured in
Best Organic Eyeshadows
Your Authors and Guides
Article Author
Heather
Patton
Article Author
Jennifer
Trimbee
Article Author
Samantha
Dewitt
Your Authors and Guides
Article Author
Heather Patton
Article Author
Jennifer Trimbee
Article Author
Samantha Dewitt

How to Choose the Best Organic Eyeshadow

Eyeshadow is part of the morning routine of a whole lot of people, but are you using the best type of eyeshadow? If you’re not using organic then you could definitely be missing something. That’s because organic eyeshadows are designed to be even better for your skin and to be safer for you to use all the time. You shouldn’t have to worry about chemicals and additives being used in your products. With any of these, you’re not going to have to, and you’re going to have plenty of other great features still.

Best Organic Eyeshadows

Package Size: What size is the package? Is it a good value for the amount of money that you’re spending? This is going to be personal for you.

Product Buying Icon

Number of Colors: How many colors do you get to choose from? Different colors are definitely going to let you express your individuality even more.

How to Choose the Best Organic Eyeshadow

Colors: What shade is the eyeshadow that you’ve chosen? Is it natural or pink or something else entirely? You want something that fits your style.

Product Buying Icon

Style: Are you getting a matte finish, a shimmer finish or something somewhere in between? This is also about personal preference.

Best Organic Eyeshadows

Made in USA: You may want a product that’s made in the USA, where you know what the rules and the standards are for makeup.

Product Intro Icon

Cruelty-Free: Is the product tested on animals or is it cruelty-free? You can definitely feel better about using cruelty-free products.

Top 10 Products

Eyeshadow is one of those things that you’re going to find absolutely everywhere, but you’re not always going to find organic options everywhere. We’ve gone through a whole bunch of different options to make sure that these are great quality and that they’re organic. That way, you know you’re getting the look you want but you’re also getting some of the other features you’ll really like. The key is making sure that you choose the right colors to highlight your own personal preferences and the style that you love the most.

NU EVOLUTION Pressed Eye Shadow

NU EVOLUTION Pressed Eye Shadow
Available in 13 different color options, this organic eyeshadow gives you a copper color with a shimmer style that’s going to draw just the right amount of attention to your eyes. It’s made in the USA and it’s cruelty-free, so you know exactly what you’re getting and you know that you can feel a whole lot better about using it. You don’t have to worry about this product being tested or used on animals. What’s even better is that it’s part of the ‘green cosmetics’ movement, which means it’s fully natural and organic and more. There are no parabens, no artificial dyes, no petroleum, no toxins and none of the other harmful ingredients that you definitely don’t want to be putting on your body. Instead, you’re getting an eyeshadow that you can really enjoy using, every single day.
Check Price NowReview Top Pick

Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Eyeshadow

Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Eyeshadow
Our budget pick is actually a duo where you’re going to get two different natural shades in a matte finish. This is going to give you a little sleeker and more polished look, but it’s also going to be something you can feel great about using because this eyeshadow and all of the other 12 colors that you can choose from are cruelty-free. Plus, they’re fully natural, organic and vegan. All of that together means that you’re getting something you can really feel great about sharing with others and putting on your skin. The whole eyeshadow here is made with pigments, minerals, and natural vitamins, which are all clean and clear. They’re also beautiful colors that come right from the earth, so you’re not getting artificial dyes, but you are getting some great colors that you can enjoy using.
Check Price NowReview Budget Pick

BaeBlu Organic Eyeshadow

BaeBlu Organic Eyeshadow
This pressed powder is a deep brown color and gives you just the right amount of shimmer when it’s applied. It’s designed to be velvety smooth, which is definitely something that you can appreciate when it comes to your eyes, right? Plus, it’s pigmented in just the right way and actually reacts to water, creating an even better look with just a little bit added. You’ll be able to choose between 18 different colors to get the perfect look for you personally. Made entirely with organic ingredients, you’re going to love this product because it has none of the artificial stuff you don’t want. There’s no parabens, no gluten, no petroleum-based oils, no alcohol, no talk, fillers, preservatives, chemicals or fragrances and it’s fully cruelty-free. That means you’re getting nothing but the color and the natural ingredients you want.
Check Price Now

RMS Beauty Eyeshadow

RMS Beauty Eyeshadow
The pale pink color is only part of what makes this one of the best organic eyeshadow options you’re going to find. It’s also available in plenty of other colors, so you can get a style that matches your personality and your personal preference. The shimmer style is going to add just the right amount of accent when you wear it and the fact that you can add a little bit of water to get even more pigment and a buildable look means that this is super unique. You’ll have a soft and silky texture to the eyeshadow and because it’s non-toxic, non-GMO and free of plenty of other chemicals and additives, you can feel great about using it on your skin. It’s also completely cruelty-free, which is another aspect you’re going to want to share.
Check Price Now

Lavera Mineral Eyeshadow

Lavera Mineral Eyeshadow
You’ll have four eyeshadows in one palette here and you’re definitely going to love all of them because they’re different shades of tan and brown. You can use them in plenty of different combinations and you can really enjoy the fact that this eyeshadow has a little bit of shimmer to it that makes it even better when applied. Plus you get hydration benefits because the colors themselves include argon oil, shea butter, and coconut oil. All of this is going to be great for your skin in a number of different ways and great for the way you feel as well. Completely cruelty-free, this eyeshadow palette is made entirely with plant-based ingredients and is fully gluten-free. Just about anyone will be able to wear this product and you can choose between a few different palettes to make sure you get the one that fits you.
Check Price Now

Luxury by Sofia Eyeshadow

Luxury by Sofia Eyeshadow
If you want natural organic eyeshadow you’re not going to want to look any further than this one. Completely crease-resistant, this eyeshadow comes in several different colors so you can express your own interests and your own personal style. You’ll also be able to get a lot of pigment, which means your eyeshadow lasts longer because you don’t need as much to get the look you want. You get all kinds of natural ingredients included in this eyeshadow, including thyme, olive and rosemary leaf extracts, among plenty of others. You’re getting an eyeshadow that has just the right amount of shimmer to give you some added style. It also is made right in the USA and it’s fully cruelty-free. That means you don’t have to worry about animal testing and what it could mean for your products.
Check Price Now

Physicians Formula Organic Wear

Physicians Formula Organic Wear
You’re not quite getting organic black eyeshadow here, but you are getting a sleek duo that’s going to give you quality and some beautiful style, no matter how you choose to use it. All you have to do is put on just a little bit of this matte eyeshadow and you’re going to see the great results that you want for you look of the day. It’s cruelty-free, so you can feel great about using it, and it’s full of all kinds of natural and organic ingredients, which means it’s going to be a whole lot better for your skin than most cosmetic products. This eyeshadow has been approved even for sensitive eyes and it’s full of ingredients like organic corn starch, mica, and jojoba oil. You won’t find any kind of synthetic colors or fragrances and you definitely won’t find parabens, preservatives or GMO’s.
Check Price Now

Antonym to the Moon and Black Eye Shadow

Antonym to the Moon and Black Eye Shadow
This eyeshadow set is going to give you several colors that are going to complement each other and make sure that you can get the perfect look that you’re hoping for. There’s a little bit of light and a little bit of dark, which is definitely going to provide you with balance and it’s going to make sure you can get the right highlights, lowlights and more. On top of that, it has a matte finish to really seal the sleek look. It’s made with plenty of natural and healthy ingredients and at least 99.64% of those ingredients are natural in origin. Over 11% are from organic farming as well. This eyeshadow is not tested on animals and it’s super smooth, soft and comfortable to use however you like. You’ll really like blending these shades together to create your own unique look and you’ll be able to accentuate the different pigments to get a deeper tone.
Check Price Now

Aqua Boudoir Organic Eye Shadow

Here you’re going to have a simple eyeshadow that is fully natural and certified to have at least 85% organic ingredients. That means you can feel great about using it and you can definitely enjoy the look and overall style of it too. The finish is a matte, so you’re going to have a good color without the added shine. You’re also going to get some moisturizing benefits because of ingredients that are in here, but you’re going to like the ingredients that it doesn’t include even better. You’re not going to have parabens, petrochemicals, phthalates, synthetic fragrances or dyes, sulfates, lead, gluten or preservatives. On top of all of that this product is fully vegan as well. Altogether, these benefits are going to make it one of the best choices you’ll find anywhere for eyeshadow.
Here you’re going to have a simple eyeshadow that is fully natural and certified to have at least 85% organic ingredients. That means you can feel great about using it and you can definitely enjoy the look and overall style of it too. The finish is a matte, so you’re going to have a good color without the added shine. You’re also going to get some moisturizing benefits because of ingredients that are in here, but you’re going to like the ingredients that it doesn’t include even better. You’re not going to have parabens, petrochemicals, phthalates, synthetic fragrances or dyes, sulfates, lead, gluten or preservatives. On top of all of that this product is fully vegan as well. Altogether, these benefits are going to make it one of the best choices you’ll find anywhere for eyeshadow.
Check Price Now

pureBIO Organic Eyeshadow

This is one of those organic eyeshadow brands you’re going to want to take a closer look at because the products are great. You get a metallic brass color here with just the right amount of shimmer to really make your eyes pop. On top of that, you’ll have the full color that you want and a texture that’s somewhere in between a powder and a cream. You get to apply it either dry or wet to get just the right look for your personal style and preference. This product is designed to last up to 12 hours and it’s fully organic and vegan. You won’t find sulfates, mineral oils, formaldehyde, parabens, phthalates or a host of other chemicals in this product, so you can feel better about applying it to your skin.
This is one of those organic eyeshadow brands you’re going to want to take a closer look at because the products are great. You get a metallic brass color here with just the right amount of shimmer to really make your eyes pop. On top of that, you’ll have the full color that you want and a texture that’s somewhere in between a powder and a cream. You get to apply it either dry or wet to get just the right look for your personal style and preference. This product is designed to last up to 12 hours and it’s fully organic and vegan. You won’t find sulfates, mineral oils, formaldehyde, parabens, phthalates or a host of other chemicals in this product, so you can feel better about applying it to your skin.
Check Price Now

About the Author

Author Image

Jennifer Trimbee

Expert Researcher and Writer

Jennifer Trimbee, a lead researcher and writer at GeekWrapped, is an expert writer with many years of experience. Jennifer writes about technology, sports, outdoor, and gear products.

Learn more about Jennifer

Article last updated on:

September 29, 2019

See more reviews:

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. All prices on this site may change and those considered valid are displayed on Amazon.com

TOP PICK

NU EVOLUTION Pressed Eye Shadow

Check Price NowBest Organic Eyeshadows
Disclosure: GeekWrapped helps you find the best stuff. When readers buy the
independently chosen products on this site, we earn a commission that supports our work.
Disclosure: GeekWrapped helps you find the best stuff. When readers buy the independently chosen products on this site, we earn a commission that supports our work.
Disclosure: When readers buy the independently chosen products on this site, we earn a commission.