Disclosure: GeekWrapped helps you find the best stuff. When readers buy the independently
chosen products on this site, we earn a commission that supports our work. Find our guides here.
Disclosure: GeekWrapped helps you find the best stuff. When readers buy the independently chosen products on this site, we earn a commission that supports our work.
Disclosure: When readers buy the independently chosen products on this site, we earn a commission.

Best Shirt Stays

Expert Reviews & Buying Guide

quadcopter reviewsBest Shirt Stays

Our Recommendations

In a hurry? Here are the best products at a glance.

Trusted by millions of readers. As featured in
Expert Reviews Buying Guides

How to Choose the Best Shirt Stay

The best shirt stays are the most reliable way to make sure you always look your best, whether you’re in uniform or heading to the office for the day. To help you find the right ones for you, we researched some of the most popular brands and top selling items and put together this shirt stays buying guide. Before we get into our reviews, let’s look at some of the features you should keep in mind when shopping.

Best Shirt Stays

Style: There are a few different styles to consider. They all do the same job they just go one a little differently. So, choose from Y, garter, or stirrup style depending on which is most comfortable for you.

Best Shirt Stays

Color: Most of these come in standard black, perfect if you’re looking for something to wear under a professional uniform. There is one brand that has a few bright, fun styles if you’re looking for something with a little more personality.

How to Choose the Best Shirt Stay

Length: We didn’t provide an actual length for these stays because every single one is adjustable and will fit just able any height, build, or gender. All of the garter style stays have adjustable thigh straps, too.

Best Shirt Stays

Made In: Half of these shirt stays are made in the USA and the other half are made in China. They’re all good products but it’s nice to know that you have the option to buy American made if you want to.

Best Shirt Stays

Sure Grip Clips: There are no magnetic shirt stays here. While all of our picks have metal clips, some of them have sure grip clips. These typically have a nylon or plastic insert to help get an extra firm grip on your shirt.

Product Intro Icon

Pieces: With one exception, these all come in sets of 2. Which is really convenient since that’s how many you need to wear them properly. One of our picks comes in a set of 4 so you always have a clean pair ready.

Top 10 Products

Now that you know more about what to look for, let’s get right into our shirt stays reviews. We found a lot of awesome products so think beyond Sharp and Dapper Shirt Stays and find your next set right here. If you’re in a hurry, check out our top and budget picks first. We put them right at the top of the list so they’re easy to find. Stick around if you can, though, each of these products is truly unique. Ok, let’s go!

Shirt Stay Plus Shirt Stays

Top Pick
Shirt Stay Plus Shirt Stays are our top pick. They’re the perfect choice if you’re looking for y style shirt stays. What makes us say that? For starters, the length is adjustable so they’ll work with just about any height. They have a lot of play so everyone can get a perfect fit. The elastic straps are patented and the manufacturer tests for quality. They’re the longest lasting, most comfortable straps available. And get this, they’re designed to be worn every day. What makes us say that? They can withstand regular washing and the clasps can hold all day without damaging your shirt. This makes them a great choice for anyone in uniform and ideal police shirt stays. Plus, they’re made in the USA by a business who pays expert attention to detail.
Check Price NowReview Top Pick

Jelinda Dress Shirt Stays

Budget Pick
The best cheap shirt stays we found in our research are these Jelinda Dress Shirt Stays. These are garter-style stays with an elastic and leather thigh strap. They’re really comfortable. Like, they won’t pull your legs hairs and are easy to readjust. That’s not all. The thigh strap attaches to the shirt with 3 straps with reinforced clasps that hold really well. And, because there are 3 of them, they feel extra secure. Plus, they don’t wrinkle your shirt as much as stays with only 2 clips. These stays are fully adjustable and will fit almost everyone so they’re the perfect shirt stays for women and men. Get this, they’re available with either metal or plastic clips. Plastic clips work well with thin shirts while the metal clips are better for thicker material.
Check Price NowReview Budget Pick

Buttons & Pleats Shirt Stays

Another great choice for Y style dress shirt stays are these Buttons & Pleats Shirt Stays. A great thing about this set is that they’re made of ultra-soft elastic. They won’t chafe or irritate your skin and are comfortable enough to wear all day. Not only that, they keep their elasticity even after repetitive use. The clips are really strong, too. Not only are they made of durable metal, they have nylon teeth on the inside which get a really tight hold on your shirt. And here’s the kicker: it doesn’t matter what kind of shirt you have. These grips can hold on to any material, no matter how thick or thin it is. But don’t worry, at the end of the day, you can still get them off without a lot of fuss.
Check Price Now

Hold’Em Premium Shirt Stays

The best shirt stays for sale for anyone looking for stirrup style are the Hold’Em Premium Shirt Stays. The elastic is really soft and won’t bother your skin even if you wear them for extended periods of time. But just because they’re comfortable doesn’t mean they’re not also really durable. In fact, they keep their elasticity even after repeated uses and trips through the washing machine. We also have to mention the non-slip design. Because of how stirrup style stays are worn, it’s important that they’re non-slip. That way, you know that they’ll stay in place around your foot and won’t need constant adjusting. Now, let’s get to the clips. They’re made of strong metal and have sturdy prongs inside to get a good grip on any kind of fabric. One more thing: they’re proudly made in the USA.
Check Price Now

Luxsego Shirt Stays

Luxsego Shirt Stays are made of elastic that’s nice and soft. It’s so skin friendly, you can wear it all day and stay comfortable. Both the loops and the garters are fully adjustable and have a lot of stretch. They really will fit just about anyone. For extra strength, the strips are leather fixed to the leg strap. This will help them stay in the right position and help them last a long time. One of the best things about this product is the clamps. They’re made of rust-proof metal and have a thick pin that will last through repeated use. The plastic clamping system is really effective, too. They use circular plastic discs that snugly fit into one another when the clasp is closed. They’ll hold onto a range of fabrics without causing any damage.
Check Price Now

Comfy Clothiers Shirt Stays

Comfy Clothiers Shirt Stays are another great option if you’re partial to the stirrup style. These are some of the best shirt stays for law enforcement and uniforms in general. By providing constant tension on your shirt, they’ll keep it tucked in and looking smooth. One reason that stirrup style stays are great is because you can use them with shirts that have longer tails. If you find that shirts are sometimes too long on you, these are a great way to keep them looking neat and tidy. Something people wonder about when it comes to the stirrup style is if they stay in place when sitting. The clasps hold firm even when sitting. When you stand, they stretch out again and the tension returns. Plus, they’re adjustable and stretchy to fit just about anyone of any height or build.
Check Price Now

FancyBoy Shirt Stays

One of the things we liked most about FancyBoy Shirt Stays is that they made them fun. You might be wondering how that’s possible. How fun can shirt stays be? Well, FancyBoy makes their Y style shirt stays in a variety of colorful prints. There’s blue and red stripes, blue and white gingham, Seattle grey, and, yes, even plain black if you want something more traditional. The elastic is really soft and comfortable against your skin and they adjust to fit heights ranging from 5’4” to 6’5”. They can really fit just about anyone. One of the great things about this brand is its low profile. That means the clasps won’t show under slim fit or skinny fit pants. If you’ve tried shirt stays before but didn’t like that they were somewhat visible under your slim fit trousers, give FancyBoy a try.
Check Price Now

Hold’Em Garter Grip Shirt Stays

For a high quality product that’s made in the USA, check out these stirrup style shirt stays from Hold’Em. The soft elastic material feels great against your skin and won’t rub or cause any irritation. It’s also really strong and retains its elasticity after use. The grips are really great, too. They’re durable and really get a phenomenal grip on your shirt. Plus, they work even with thick fabrics and won’t damage the material. That said, they’re easy to remove at the end of the day. One of the perks of the stirrup style is you don’t have to worry about anything around your thighs or clips on your socks. They’re really simple to wear and easy to get one. And get this: they come with a 100% money back guarantee.
Check Price Now

Ying Mao Rong Stays

The elastic that Ying Mao Rong uses in its shirt stays is thick and long lasting but, don’t worry, it’s still comfortable against your skin. These stays truly look like suspenders that are made to keep your shirt tucked in. They’re adjustable and can fit just about any height or build. If you’re looking for women’s and men’s shirt stays that can tolerate being worn every day and handle regular trips through the washing machine, you have to check out Ying Mao Rong Stays. They’ll stay in place, too. The metal clips have plastic teeth to help them get a good grip on your shirt and work well with a variety of materials. Plus, they won’t cause any damage to the material. They’re pretty stylish looking, too, and come in blue if that’s a better fit for you.
Check Price Now

Hero's Pride Shirt Stays

While these Hero’s Pride Shirt Stays are technically garter style, they’re a little different from all the other stays we’ve looked at so far. What do we mean by that? They have the simplest design that we’ve come across. They’re a straight strap with a clasp on either end. One attaches to your shirt tail and one to your sock. That’s it. If you like the idea of shirt stays but want something that’s as unobtrusive as possible, these are a good choice. That’s not all, you actually get 4 stays with this set and they’re all adjustable so you can get the right fit. Use 2 at a time and swap them out to extend the life of each or, if you want some extra support, you could always use 2 at the same time.
Check Price Now

Discover New Gift Ideas Now

Unique Geek Gifts


Privacy guaranteed. Emails are never shared.
By clicking "Get Access" you agree to
our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. All prices on this site may change and those considered valid are displayed on Amazon.com
Review and Buying Guide GeekWrapped