Disclosure: GeekWrapped is a list of the best products. When readers buy our independently
chosen editorial picks, we earn affiliate commissions that support our work. Find our guides here.
Disclosure: GeekWrapped is a list of the best products. When readers buy our independently chosen editorial picks, we earn affiliate commissions that support our work.
Disclosure: When readers buy products on this site, we earn affiliate commissions that support our work.

Realistic Mermaid Tails

Reviews and Buying Guide

ReviewReview

How to Choose a Realistic Mermaid Tail

Most people who dream of being a mermaid realize that they have two big problems, their legs.  Technology may not have reached the point of flying cars yet, but it has solved that problem by inventing realistic mermaid tails.  Yes, you read that right.  You can now slip into your very own mermaid tail and let all of your childhood dreams come true.  The mermaid tail market features tails of all kinds of materials, styles, and colors, so you should have no problem finding the perfect one for you.  

Before you drown in all of the options, you should check out some of our realistic mermaid tail reviews.  We picked ten that make the biggest splash in our opinion. Before we dive into those, here are the specs you should keep in mind while you’re shopping.

Review and Buying Guide

Handmade

When you start looking into realistic mermaid tails, you will find that some are handmade while others are manufactured.  You will usually find more detail in the handmade tails, but you will also end up paying a lot more for them.

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size

Some mermaid tail retailers will make tails customized to your measurements.  This will give you a much better fit, which will make swimming easier. Again, this option is going to cost more, but it might be worth it to you.

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable

This is the reason you’re here.  Some mermaid tails are designed to be functional while others are not.  If you want the most realistic mermaid tail experience, you’re going to want to find a tail that you can actually swim in.

Review and Buying Guide

Material

Most of the realistic mermaid tails are made out of latex, silicone, or a mix of silicone and other materials.  The quality of the silicone varies with price, but the better the silicone is, the more lifelike the mermaid tail will move and feel.

Review and Buying Guide

Colors

The color of the tail is another one of the more exciting details to consider.  You’ll find that some tails come in a variety of beautiful colors so you can pick your favorite.  You may even have the option to customize colors.

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping Time

Lastly, you’ll want to take shipping time into consideration.  If the mermaid tail is custom or handmade, it could take weeks for it to be shipped.  If you’re in a rush, you might prefer a manufactured tail that can be shipped immediately.

Reviews and Buying Guide

When we set out on our journey to uncover the best realistic mermaid tails, we ended up finding several options that would suit a variety of people.  Some tails that were awesome for swimming, and we found some that were better suited for land, however ironic that may be.  We also saw several that are perfect for beginners looking to just dip their toes, or fins, into the pool of mermaid tails, while others could hold up to the expectations of the most serious merfolk.

If budget is a concern for you, we’ve got you covered too with some great, cheap realistic mermaid tails for sale.  Our ten favorites should be more than enough to get you started with your own search for the best realistic mermaid tail.

GeekWrapped Top Pick

MerNation Genesis Edition

Bestsselling Product
Review and Buying Guide

Handmade
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Material
100% Silicone

Review and Buying Guide

Color
Any

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping
6-8 weeks

When you picture a mermaid tail, the MerNation Genesis Edition comes pretty close to the image in your mind.  MerNation pays great attention to detail from top to fin in every single scale.  While they have other options available, this particular tail happens to be perfect for beginners because it is lightweight and easy to use.

However, it is still the kind of quality that serious merfolk could appreciate.  It is made from 100% Dragon Skin Silicone, and it is custom-sized using their “duct tape dummy” process.  You can also customize the color by choosing any two colors to be blended together.  It has a molded fluke shape, which helps you to effortlessly glide through the water.  At the end of the molded fluke, you’ll find small openings that help trapped water escape when you’re done.

The creators of these custom mermaid tails know exactly how to design a great mermaid tail, and they will guide you through the entire process making sure that the tail is exactly how you want it.  Here’s the best part: you will even receive video and photo updates as your tail is being made.  The entire process will take 6-8 weeks, but it is more than worth the wait.

Check Price Now

Fin Fun Mermaid Tail

Best Cheap Product
Review and Buying Guide

Handmade
No

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size
No

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Material
Neoprene

Review and Buying Guide

Color
Various

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping
Immidiate

If you’re working with a limited budget, the Fin Fun Mermaid Tail is right up your alley.  Compared to handmade tails, these manufactured tails are much more affordable.  If you’re just looking for fun pool activity to enjoy this summer, this tail will get the job done.  Kids and adults will be able to enjoy hours of swimming in these cheap mermaid tails.

The tail is made out of comfortable swimsuit material with a neoprene-covered monofin.  The monofin is designed to mimic a natural mermaid motion, and the tips of the fin are reinforced to prevent any holes, tearing, or shredding.  With the fin, you’ll be able to quickly and easily glide through the water.  If for any reason you need to take the fin off when you are in the water, Fin Fun designed the tails, so you can kick the monofin off and free your feet in seconds.  This is an important safety feature for beginners and children.  The tails can be ordered in a variety of sizes based on the company’s sizing chart, and there are nine fun colors to choose from.  One last thing: you can enjoy your new tail right away because they are already made and ready to ship.  If you’re looking for more cheap mermaid tails, you can find them here.

Check Price NowGeekWrapped Budget Pick

MerNation Signature Line

Bestsselling Product
Review and Buying Guide

Handmade
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Material
100% Silicone

Review and Buying Guide

Color
Any

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping
8-12 weeks

As you probably noticed with our top pick, MerNation doesn’t mess around when it comes to creating high-quality mermaid tails, and the MerNation Signature Line is their most detailed tail.  It comes at a pretty hefty price, but the intricate detail in every inch of these tails makes it well worth the money and 8-12 weeks you’ll have to wait for it to be made.

For this tail, MerNation uses 100% Dragon Skin Platinum Cure Silicone, which is the top-of-the-line material for making safe and realistic tails.  Your measurements will be used to mold the scales and fluke to fit you perfectly.  While you’re gracefully swimming through the water, you’ll be able to show off the stunning details of your tail.  

You can choose any color combination, and you can add glitter, highlighting, extra fins, and detailed paint schemes for additional costs.  MerNation ensures the paints will not fade, scrape off, or change color by creating a special formula that bonds directly to the tail.  You also get to choose the fin inside the fluke.  You can choose a Finis Wave, Rapid, or Trainer monofin.  Your imagination is the only limit to the design of the MerNation Signature Line mermaid tail.

Check Price Now

EvaTail Custom Mermaid Tail

Best Cheap Product
Review and Buying Guide

Handmade
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Material
100% Silicone

Review and Buying Guide

Color
Any

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping
2-3 months

The EvaTail Custom Mermaid Tail is another tail that can be made based on your sketches.  Of course, the more customizations you make, the more money you will be paying.  All of the mermaid tails are made based on your measurements so you will be able to get the perfect fit.  

The base option includes a tail made with EvaTail forms without additional fins.  This package includes a monofin, scales, heel fins, a tail fin, and painting in up to three colors.  If you are willing to pay more, you can add more fins to the tail.  If you still aren’t able to find an option that looks like your dream tail, you can make a unique order that is completely customizable.

Since you have so many customization options, you should expect to wait 2-3 months for your mermaid tail to be shipped.  You will receive photos of your tail throughout the process so any adjustments can be made.

EvaTail even throws in a few surprise gifts with the tail.  Once you get your tail, you can use it in the pool or for stunning photo shoots.  A photo shoot will really allow you to show off the beautiful paint and Dragon Skin silicone.

Check Price Now

MerNation Full Silicone Tail

Bestsselling Product
Review and Buying Guide

Handmade
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Material
100% Silicone

Review and Buying Guide

Color
Any

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping
8-10 weeks

The MerNation Full Silicone Tail is another tail with several customization options. However, this mermaid tail is only one color, which means you can choose any color without shading, blending or variations.  As with the other MerNation tails, you can send in your measurements and have a tail custom-made to fit you.  

This tail is also made from 100% Dragon Skin Platinum Cure Silicone, so the tail meets the industry’s safety standards.  Each of the tails comes with a Finis Wave or Rapid monofin for the fluke.  If you want to add extra fins for extra flare, you have several options including dorsal, pec, heel, calf, and hip fins.  If that still isn’t enough flare for you, you can add scale highlight, a glitter top coat, or even individual glitter scale accents.  Each of these additional features varies by price, but they are great ways to make a completely unique mermaid tail to match your taste and personality.

You will have to wait 8-10 weeks for your custom-made mermaid tail to be shipped, but perfection can’t be rushed.  Once you get to put on your mermaid tail for the very first time, you will be happy that you waited.

Check Price Now

PearlieMae Swimmable Tail

Best Cheap Product
Review and Buying Guide

Handmade
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Material
100% Silicone

Review and Buying Guide

Color
Any

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping
3 months

Another great option for a custom-made mermaid tail is the PearlieMae Swimmable Tail.  As the name suggests, this tail is designed for swimming like real mermaid tails.  
You will find that this mermaid tail is also crafted from the popular Dragon Skin Platinum Cure Silicone, so you know that it is safe for your skin.  The creators of the PearlieMae Swimmable Tail handcraft each individual scale on the tail.  Most tails will feature over 1,000 scales, and you have the creative freedom to choose the design and colors of them.  Molded within the fluke of the tail, there is a custom-fit polycarbonate monofin.

You also have the option of adding up to four side fins at no additional cost.  In order to make sure the tail fits you best, PearlieMae will provide you with step-by-step instructions to create a mannequin of your body from the waist down. The total process could take about three months. The best part is that these tails are covered by a one-year warranty to fix any structural problems that may result from normal use.  The warranty shipping agreement is 50/50, so you only need to pay to ship the tail back to the creator.

Check Price Now

CreationMermaid Tail

Bestsselling Product
Review and Buying Guide

Handmade
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Material
Sequin + Silicone

Review and Buying Guide

Color
Blue or Pink

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping
1-2 months

If your dream is to own a complete mermaid ensemble without breaking the bank, the CreationMermaid Tail is perfect for you.  The tail includes a matching top with adjustable fasteners and straps to get the best fit.

This tail is a bit different from other handmade tails you will find on the market.  Rather than being made entirely from the best silicone, you will find that the majority of the tail is made from fabric.  In fact, both the tail and the top are made out of a sequin-covered fabric.  Attached to the fabric of the tail, you will find two small silicone fins on the sides and one on the back.  This design makes the tail more affordable, but don’t worry.  The monofin fluke is also made out of silicone, so it is perfect for swimming.  

The tail is handmade to fit your custom measurements, and you can choose from a blue or pink mermaid tail.  You should expect to wait 1-2 months for your handmade tail to be shipped.  The bottom line is this: this mermaid tail is perfect for adults and children who are just looking to have some fun.  It is affordable, but you are still getting a custom, handmade tail.

Check Price Now

Sirenalia Silicone Mermaid Tail

Best Cheap Product
Review and Buying Guide

Handmade
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Material
100% Silicone

Review and Buying Guide

Color
Any

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping
1 month

The Sirenalia Silicone Mermaid Tail is another handmade silicone tail.  Like most realistic mermaid tails for swimming, this tail is made with the 100% Dragon Skin Platinum Cure silicone.  This tail comes with a one-year limited warranty to fix any scratches or tears you might end up with in the silicone.  It is also completely customizable.  You will be able to send in your measurements as well as a filled-in template to help get the design process started.

  You can currently choose any color and add on any additional fins.  The fluke comes with a monofin, and you have the option of choosing from three different fluke shapes.  If you’re not concerned with a budget, you can make several extra additions to create your perfect mermaid tail. The creators really give you a lot of freedom when it comes to customizing your tail, and they will work with you to come up with a functional design that you love.  Once the tail has been started, it should take about one month for it to be completed and ready to ship.  After you get your tail and get the hang of swimming, you might be interested in heading to one of the company’s annual mermaid retreats.

Check Price Now

Finfolk Productions Tail

Bestsselling Product
Review and Buying Guide

Handmade
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Material
100% Silicone

Review and Buying Guide

Color
Any

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping
6-8 weeks

The Finfolk Productions Tail is another stunning handmade tail.  Like some of the other realistic mermaid tails for sale, it is made entirely from 100% Dragon Skin Platinum Cure Silicone.  The tails are designed to fit your custom measurements and aesthetic preferences, so you have complete creative freedom when it comes to choosing the color.  The basic mermaid tail order will include a Finis Trainer monofin in the fluke and a complimentary set of ankle fins.  You even have the option of swapping out the ankle fins for a mermaid top.  
Of course, more money will give you even more options to customize the mermaid tail, and you will have to wait about 6-8 weeks for it to be completed.  Now, you might be wondering what sets these mermaid tails apart from the other mermaid tails for sale.  Well, the best part of these mermaid tails is that they are helping the environment.  You see, the company generously donates portions of their proceeds to help oceanic conservation and marine life research.  In fact, they have helped remove over 1,000 pounds of human-made debris from the sea, and they have donated to marine research, rescue, and rehabilitation organizations.

Check Price Now

TFArtistry Realistic Tail

Best Cheap Product
Review and Buying Guide

Handmade
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Custom Size
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Swimmable
Yes

Review and Buying Guide

Material
100% Silicone

Review and Buying Guide

Color
Any

Review and Buying Guide

Shipping
6-8 weeks

The last of our favorite mermaid tails for sale is the TFArtistry Realistic Tail.  TFArtistry goes above and beyond to create more than a mermaid tail.  The artist uses her background in special effects makeup and science to craft one-of-a-kind mermaid tails. These realistic mermaid tails for adults are handmade to fit the custom measurements of your body.  Not only are they made to fit your body, but they are also made to fit your mermaid personality.  Every single tail is painted to suit the individual’s preferences and to look as realistic as possible.  They come with durable Waves Rapid monofin, so you will glide through the water with speed and grace.  
When you’re not swimming, the Platinum Cured Silicone creates the perfect fit and buoyancy, so you will have a more realistic experience.  The artist’s special effects experience gives the tails a realistic feel and texture.  When you look at them through the water, they will shimmer with a pearlized pigment.  All of the scales are 3D and hand sculpted to resemble real marine shapes as well as shapes inspired by mermaid myths.  If you are looking for a mermaid tail that reaches a new level of artistry, you will love the TFArtistry realistic Tail.

Check Price Now

Can't get enough of all this mermaidy goodness? We totally get it. :)

Check out our other reviews for the best mermaid tails for swimming, mermaid tails for kids, silicone mermaid tails, and other mermaid tails for sale. Have fun and get ready to make a splash!

Discover Fun and Unique Geek Gifts!

Unique Geek Gifts

GET FREEBIES AND EXCLUSIVE OFFERS!
SUBSCRIBE TO THE FREE NEWSLETTER:

Privacy guaranteed. Emails are never shared.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. All prices on this site may change and those considered valid are displayed on Amazon.com

IMPORTANT WARNING AND DISCLAIMER

The products listed here may contain small parts that are choking hazards for children! Toys can pose a hazard to babies and young children – they can choke, suffocate, or otherwise harm the child. Young children explore their world by putting things in their mouths, but children under three years of age do not have a well-developed coughing reflex and will choke easily on small items. All children, regardless of age, need close supervision with any toys to help prevent accidents from happening. Adult supervision is required at all times! Only ever use the products shown in very shallow and safe water and at your own risk.

Always follow the manufacturer's guidelines for age appropriateness as shown on the product's official packaging. Only buy toys that are right for your child’s age! Should the product's packaging or other product information (especially in regards to recommended age) deviate from the information presented here, DO NOT give the product to your child! All information presented here is for entertainment purposes only. We do not assume any liability for the information presented here. It is your responsibility to ensure that products are age appropriate and safe to use for your child. Please always be careful, safety comes first.

Reviews and Buying Guide GeekWrapped